Jeff Carroll

Hilliard Family Jefferson Fellow
Cambridge, Ohio
B.A. The Ohio State University (2013)
M.A. Georgia State University (2016)
Graduate School of Arts & Sciences


Jeff Carroll is a Ph.D. candidate in philosophy at the University of Virginia. His research is focused on issues in political and social philosophy, the philosophy of law and topics at the intersection of philosophy, politics, and economics (PPE). Jeff specializes in how to theorize about justice and political normativity, and has related interests in democratic theory. He was an Adam Smith Fellow through the Mercatus Center in 2017-2018 and 2018-2019, and received a Humane Studies Fellowship in 2018-2019. Jeff received his B.A. from The Ohio State University in philosophy and political science and his M.A. from Georgia State University.

Thesis Description:

Dynamic Ideal Theory
My dissertation defends a new methodological approach to how we theorize about political normativity. In contrast to many static theories of political normativity that operate analogous to how Google Maps works in travel, I argue for a dynamic methodology that is more analogous to how scientific practice proceeds. This means that theorizing should be highly fallibilistic and, if necessary, revisionistic. Still, this is a form of ideal theorizing that explores the feasibility frontier of what is politically possible. The central aim of the dissertation is to bring together, on the one hand, the need to take seriously the epistemic limitations of human beings as theorists and, on the other, the need to explore and pursue more just ways of organizing our shared political life.

Connect with our community

View Fellows


David and Jane Walentas

A transformational gift for UVA — $100 million to benefit first-generation students

Read more


The Jefferson Scholarship is the premier undergraduate scholarship at the University of Virginia. Scholars are selected through a rigorous selection process that is based on exceptional performance in the areas of leadership, scholarship and citizenship.

Read more


The Jefferson Scholars Foundation, like its namesake, knows that virtue and talent come from all walks of life. Indeed it is this knowledge that drives the Foundation to search the world over for its recipients.

Read more